Repressed Memories vs. Everyday Forgetfulness

Bella Dippenaar
Like me

In the world of psychology, few topics have stirred as much debate and intrigue as the concept of suppressed memories. We’ve all seen it play out dramatically in movies, where a character’s forgotten past suddenly resurfaces, triggered by a seemingly innocuous event. But do these suppressed memories exist, or are they simply a product of fiction? In this exploration, we delve into the fascinating realm of repressed memories, separating fact from fiction.

Once upon a time, the concept of repressed memories was widely accepted within the field of psychology. It was so influential that it led to the incarceration of some individuals who sought psychotherapy in hopes of unearthing long-buried memories from their past. However, as time has passed, this topic has become increasingly contentious, with varying viewpoints among professionals.

According to a study conducted by the University of California, Irvine, published in the Journal of the Association for Psychological Science in 2013, a significant percentage of clinical psychologists, ranging from sixty to ninety percent (varying by therapist type), still believe in the existence of repressed memories, albeit in very rare instances. Additionally, a substantial portion of the general population—43% to 75%—holds the belief that forgotten memories can be retrieved through specific techniques. On the flip side, almost 70% of research psychologists maintain that suppressed memories are a mere myth.

Researchers vs. Medical Practitioners

The stark contrast in beliefs between research psychologists and medical professionals highlights a crucial divide in the understanding of repressed memories. Renowned psychologist Chris French of the University of London points out that despite the enduring acceptance of the psychoanalytic concept of repression, there is a distinct lack of compelling evidence to support its existence.

One possible explanation for this divide, as suggested by Lawrence Patihis, a researcher involved in the study, lies in the differing approaches of physicians and researchers. Physicians often rely on their clinical experiences, which may include anecdotal accounts of cures resulting from recalling repressed memories. In contrast, researchers tend to place greater emphasis on experimental data.

Nature of Trauma and Memory

To bolster the case against repressed memories, it’s essential to understand the nature of memory and how traumatic experiences are stored. Contrary to popular belief, traumatic events tend to be remembered vividly precisely because of the strong emotional reactions they elicit. These are the memories commonly associated with repression.

However, traumatic events that don’t trigger intense emotional reactions can go unremembered. For instance, a child might not fully grasp the trauma of an event, resulting in a lack of emotional reaction. These memories are more likely to be forgotten than any other type.

A study titled “Recall of Childhood Trauma: A Prospective Study of Women’s Memories of Child Sexual Abuse,” published in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, sheds light on this phenomenon. It revealed that 38% of adults with a high likelihood of childhood abuse had forgotten their traumatic experiences as adults.

Real-life accounts offer a glimpse into the complex nature of repressed memories. One participant in a study initially insisted she had never been a victim of sexual abuse. However, further questioning led her to recall her uncle’s actions, which had dire consequences. In this case, the woman was one of three children her uncle was accused of abusing, and his actions ultimately resulted in his fatal confrontation with the mother of one of the children. The adult woman had little recollection of her early life, including both happy and sad memories.

Similarly, Claudia, a woman attending group therapy for weight loss, suddenly recollected being sexually abused by her older brother during her childhood. This revelation occurred without any apparent trigger. Claudia’s journey of memory recovery unfolded as she explored her deceased brother’s room, which had largely remained untouched since he died in Vietnam nearly fifteen years prior. In his closet, she stumbled upon a pair of handcuffs, and within a diary, she found disturbing accounts of alleged sexual experiments with his sister.

The debate surrounding repressed memories remains intricate and contentious. While some continue to believe in their existence, the lack of empirical evidence raises significant doubts. The nature of trauma and memory further complicates the matter, with traumatic events triggering strong recollections, while others may fade into obscurity.

Memory is a fascinating facet of human cognition, and its interaction with trauma often leads to intriguing phenomena. In this exploration, we delve into the intricate relationship between memory and trauma, shedding light on the enigmatic world of memory loss linked to traumatic experiences.

Why Traumatic Memories Persist

One of the fundamental aspects of memory is the role of emotion. Traumatic events tend to leave an indelible mark on our memory due to the intense emotional responses they evoke. This section delves into why traumatic memories tend to persist with remarkable clarity.

The Mechanisms of Memory Suppression

Trauma can also have the opposite effect, causing memories to become suppressed or inaccessible. This section unravels the mechanisms behind memory suppression in response to trauma, exploring the factors that lead to the shrouding of distressing experiences.

Trauma-Induced Amnesia

Amnesia, a condition often portrayed in movies and literature, is a genuine consequence of trauma. Here, we investigate the phenomenon of trauma-induced amnesia, where individuals experience memory loss as a direct result of traumatic events.

The Elusive Nature of Memory

Not all traumatic experiences result in vivid or suppressed memories. Some traumas fade into obscurity, rendering them forgotten. This section explores why certain traumatic events fail to leave a lasting imprint on memory.

Intriguingly, some individuals claim to have recovered memories of traumatic events after a long period of forgetting. This section delves into the complexity of recovered memories, examining the factors that might lead to their resurgence.

The Intricacies of Memory and Health

Memory is not only integral to our cognitive function but also plays a vital role in overall health and well-being. In this exploration, we delve into the complex relationship between memory and health, shedding light on the various health concerns associated with memory loss.

Cognitive Decline and Aging

Aging is a natural process that often comes with cognitive changes, including memory decline. This section delves into the impact of aging on memory and the potential health concerns that arise as a result.


Dementia is a progressive neurological disorder characterized by severe memory loss and cognitive decline. Here, we examine the various forms of dementia, their effects on memory, and the profound health implications for individuals and their caregivers.

Alzheimer’s Disease

Alzheimer’s disease is a devastating condition that primarily affects memory and cognitive function. This section explores the intricate connection between Alzheimer’s disease and memory loss, highlighting the profound health challenges it presents.

Unresolved traumatic memories can have a significant impact on mental health. This section delves into the health concerns associated with repressed or traumatic memories, including the potential for conditions like post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

Stress and Memory

Stress can both impact memory and be influenced by memory-related concerns. Here, we explore the bidirectional relationship between stress and memory, shedding light on the potential health risks associated with chronic stress.

Lifestyle Factors and Memory

Certain lifestyle choices can significantly impact memory and overall health. This section examines the role of factors like diet, exercise, sleep, and social engagement in preserving memory and well-being.

Memory and Mental Health

Mental health disorders can contribute to memory-related concerns, and memory issues can, in turn, exacerbate mental health challenges. In this final section, we discuss the importance of seeking balance and professional support to address memory-related health concerns and maintain overall well-being.

In the end, the concept of suppressed memories continues to intrigue and mystify, challenging our understanding of the human mind. Whether fact or fiction, it serves as a reminder of the intricate tapestry of memory, trauma, and the enigmatic workings of the human psyche.